• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Sergio's

Sergio's, located at 503 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY, is a premier Italian dining destination renowned for its exquisite cuisine and attentive service. Guests rave about the exceptional quality and attention to detail in every dish, from the tender baby artichokes to the luxurious Osso Buco Risotto. The lively atmosphere is perfect for celebrations or intimate dinners, with a knowledgeable staff committed to ensuring a memorable experience. With a diverse wine selection and delightful desserts like the creamy tiramisu, Sergio's consistently delivers exceptional meals that leave diners satisfied and eager to return. It's a gem in the heart of Pelham.

Sergio's: Reviews & Ratings

Jose Sandoval
Jose Sandoval

Amazing food, appetizers, meal and dessert. All amazing. Our server was very helpful, quick, friendly knowledgeable. I would recommend this place to everybody.

romina romi
romina romi

We had the best time here . Staff extremely nice and friendly, so polite. The food was delicious and fresh. Great wine selection as well . The owner was very friendly too. Highly recommended!!

Richard Federbusch
Richard Federbusch

This place is ideal for small group celebrations or simply to enjoy a top notch Italian meal. This is a high end, bustling Italian eatery where each course is prepared with extra care and extraordinary attention to detail resulting in phenominal presentation. I started with the baby artichokes as my appetizer. The blend of garlic and olive oil was seasoned perfectly and was not too overwhelming. The artichokes were tender and melted in my mouth. The quality was right up there with what you would expect if you were in Rome. For my main, I went with the Osso Buco Risotto special. Simply amazing! The portion was generous and tasty and exquisitely presented. We wrapped up the meal with the tiramisu for dessert. It was moist and creamy and simply divine. Service was friendly and attentive. Valet parking was professional and efficient. For upscale Italian, this is where you want to go.

Joseph Duggan
Joseph Duggan

Sergio's has been my go to place for a good meal, excellent service, warm hospitality, and important conversations. The food and team culture is 100% consistent. I never walk away anything less than totally satisfied. It is a gem with an excellent price point.

Laura Irving
Laura Irving

My friends and I came for a much-needed relaxing dinner and were enjoying ourselves — until a family decided the restaurant was their personal living room. What started as a pleasant evening turned into a chaotic one, with loud, disruptive behavior and even acrobatics at their table. Despite requests, the family continued acting inappropriately for a public space. To their credit, the staff handled the situation with grace. The servers did their best, and management kindly offered to move us to a different floor, which made all the difference. You can’t reason with entitlement, but you can appreciate a team that goes above and beyond to protect the dining experience for other guests. We’ll 100% be back — not just for the great food, but for the way the staff took care of us. Highly recommend.

Jonila Fetiu
Jonila Fetiu

Sergio’s of Pelham is fantastic — super fresh seafood, amazing truffle ravioli, and one of the best desserts I’ve ever had. Great ambiance and top-notch quality all around.

kimberly root
kimberly root

A staple solid Italian restaurant in town. I've had the pleasure of eating here multiple times over the years ( including my birthday last year) I have also had take out before. I must give a shout out to the manager and the team for taking such good care of me and my takeout order last night on the eve of Easter when they were beyond busy. The manager made sure everything was in order and went above and beyond for me. Excellent customer service along with the delicious food we ordered. Cesar salad, Pappardelle Bolognese and the Napoleon were all excellent. If you haven't already experienced Sergio's I'd make sure you give them a try. You won't be disappointed! They are very accommodating here. They are also kid friendly and handicap accessible. Thank you once again Sergio's for a wonderful experience!

Ina Cicchiello-Allaraj
Ina Cicchiello-Allaraj

The food was delicious, and the service was outstanding! Tony, the host, was incredibly accommodating and found us a table even though we didn’t have a reservation on a packed Women’s Day. The atmosphere was beautiful, with a modern and inviting feel. Highly recommend this place!

Location

  • Sergio's
    503 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803, United States Hotline: +1 914-278-9771

Welcome to Sergio's, a hidden gem nestled at 503 Fifth Ave in Pelham, NY. This upscale Italian eatery is not just a restaurant; it's a culinary experience that combines warm hospitality with exquisite dishes. With a phone number for reservations at +1 914-278-9771, it's the kind of place you’ll want to keep coming back to.

The essence of Sergio's lies in its commitment to quality and attention to detail. Guests have raved about the delicious and fresh food, paired with an impressive wine selection that enhances every meal. Whether you’re indulging in their tender osso buco risotto or savoring the mouthwatering tiramisu for dessert, each course is a testament to the chefs' passionate approach to Italian cuisine. One visit and you’ll understand why it competes well with the culinary offerings in Rome itself.

Positive customer reviews highlight the exceptional service provided by the knowledgeable staff. From Jose Sandoval's admiration for the quick and friendly service to Richard Federbusch's praise for the attentiveness of the team, Sergio's stands out for its warm hospitality. Regulars like Joseph Duggan repeatedly choose Sergio's, appreciating the consistent quality that leaves diners totally satisfied after each visit.

However, it's not just about the food and service; it’s also about the atmosphere. Sergio's creates the perfect setting for both small celebrations and intimate dinners, making it a versatile spot for any occasion. When faced with disruptions, such as rowdy diners, the staff at Sergio's exhibits commendable grace under pressure, ensuring every guest has a pleasant experience. It’s these qualities that turn first-time visitors into loyal patrons.

In summary, Sergio's isn’t just another Italian restaurant; it’s a full-fledged dining destination. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or enjoying a casual meal, Sergio's promises superior food, excellent service, and an unforgettable night out. Don't miss your chance to experience it for yourself—your taste buds and heart will thank you.